Courts in Mayo return to normal after legal aid dispute

Courts in Mayo return to normal after legal aid dispute

Cathy McDarby said solicitors were relieved to return to the courts. 

After 148 days of continued strike action, solicitors working in Mayo’s criminal courts restored their services last Wednesday.

The industrial action, which was part of a nationwide dispute, came about in June as a result of the introduction of a new flat-fee model of legal aid payments by Minister for Justice Jim O’Callaghan. It resulted in significant disruption to courts around the country.

In Mayo, all solicitors resigned from the Legal Aid Board as part of an escalation of strike action during the first weeks of the dispute. The work of the criminal courts was curtailed with very few cases proceeding in either the District or Circuit Court. Where cases did proceed on a small number of occasions, members of the public would often represent themselves. The Circuit Court, which sits every three months in Mayo, only heard two trials across the July and October sittings of the court.

The standoff ended last Tuesday evening when a resolution was reached following days of talks between the Law Society and Minister O’Callaghan.

The flat-fee structure is to remain in place and multiple legal aid certificates will no longer be granted for separate and distinct cases. However, agreement was reached on an increased flat fee of €780 if the accused faces charges related to two separate and distinct cases and €1,040 for three or more separate cases while children's cases, domestic violence and custody cases will attract a fee of €780.

President of the Mayo Solicitors' Bar Association Cathy McDarby told the Western People the resolution was a fair outcome for all parties after an uncertain five months.

“We’re thrilled to be back working," said the Ballinrobe-based solicitor. "Everybody is relieved to get justice functioning properly again and to get matters moving on. For ourselves, the victims, the clients, the Gardaí, judges and courts staff, we can now start processing justice again."

Ms McDarby said solicitors had not embarked lightly on the strike action. 

“It was a very uncertain time, a very frightening and worrisome time for solicitors but we had to do what we had to do. We’re happy it’s over and we can get on with our jobs. The word is fair, it is a fair outcome for all.” 

It was back to business as usual on Wednesday morning at District Court sittings in Belmullet and Castlebar, where a special sitting was held, as a number of legal aid certificates were issued under the auspices of the new agreement.

This was in sharp contrast to 24 hours earlier at Tuesday’s sitting of Ballina District Court where 14 of 25 cases listed before Judge Mary McAveety were adjourned due to being impacted by the withdrawal of services, before the breakthrough in talks that evening.

The attention of the local courts will now turn towards addressing the large backlog of cases that has formed over the course of the strike action.

“The backlog is more than what we had during the Covid-19 pandemic,” said Ms McDarby. “But we will work very hard to clear it as quickly as possible.”

Next spring's sitting of Castlebar Circuit Criminal Court will be particularly busy with many cases adjourned from the recent sittings in October and July.

  • Published as part of the Courts Reporting Scheme.

More in this section